Why it works in Liège
Liège mixes customers who are very loyal to their neighbourhoods — the Carré, Outremeuse, the Vinâve d'Île — with a large student population (ULiège, HELMo) that changes every academic year, not to mention the regulars at the Batte market every Sunday. A paper card can't keep up with that pace; LuveLink goes into the Apple Wallet from the very first visit (Google Wallet is planned and will follow), and lets you find a customer just as easily on a market Sunday as on a night out in the Carré.